Skip to content

Screenshot-first vs typing-first task capture

3 min read

With typing-first capture, you add a task by typing it into a text field. With screenshot-first capture, you take a screenshot of the request and the app writes the task from the image.

How most to-do apps work

Most to-do apps, such as Things, Todoist and Apple Reminders, are built around a text field, though many also take voice, email or images. Typing works for tasks you plan. It works badly for requests that come in while you're busy with something else, because typing them out means stopping what you're doing.

What typing a task involves

Adding a task by typing takes these steps:

  1. Decide it's worth writing down
  2. Switch to your to-do app
  3. Click the new task field
  4. Type a title you'll understand later
  5. Choose a project, list or tag
  6. Choose a deadline
  7. Switch back and find your place

Any of them can stall. The title is hard to write once the original message is out of view, and choosing a deadline or a project means making a decision you weren't ready for. When you're busy, you skip it and plan to remember.

What capturing a screenshot involves

With the Capter desktop app, capturing the same request takes these steps:

  1. Decide it's worth capturing
  2. Press the capture shortcut, without leaving the app you're in
  3. Drag a box around the request
  4. Press Enter, or type a short note first

You don't write a title: the screenshot holds the text, the sender and the time, and Capter writes the title from it. You don't pick a project either. Capter picks tags based on the names and descriptions of the ones you've made. The deadline comes from the image when it says something like "by Friday" or "EOD". When it doesn't, type a note such as "remind me Thursday" before you press Enter.

The Windows and Mac apps add the Ctrl+PrtScrn and ⌘+` shortcuts. In a browser, take the screenshot with your system's own tool and paste it into the web app.

Screenshots need somewhere to go

On their own, screenshots of things you meant to do pile up in a folder you rarely open. Screenshot-first capture only works when each screenshot becomes a task with a deadline and a reminder. In Capter, the screenshot is saved with the task, so you can see the original request when you open it.

When typing is the better choice

Typing-first apps are the better fit for some work:

  • Planned work. When you plan a week or a sprint, the tasks come from you. Typing them into Things or Linear is quick.
  • Repeating tasks. "Pay rent on the 1st" doesn't appear in any screenshot. Type it once and set it to repeat.
  • Detailed systems. If you use GTD-style contexts and weekly reviews, a typing-first app gives you that structure.

Screenshot-first is better for requests that arrive in chat and email while you're doing something else.

Trying both for a week

To compare them, try this for five working days:

  • Keep your current to-do app.
  • Use Capter next to it. The web app works in any browser.
  • Every time you think "I'll remember that", take a screenshot and add it to Capter.

At the end of the week, look at the tasks in Capter that aren't in your other app. Those are the ones you would have tried to remember.